Audio Interview, Michael Beatty, July 6, 2012

  • EVELYN BAILEY: There we go.
  • Mike, were you born in Rochester?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: No, I'm from Detroit.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Oh.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Originally.
  • But I moved here from just south of Syracuse.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: OK.
  • And what brought you to New York?
  • I mean--
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: The job at AIDS Rochester did, actually.
  • I was in nursing in a hospital just south of Cortland,
  • and I had two friends who died from AIDS.
  • And so I volunteered at the Southern Tier AIDS Program
  • and ended up getting on their board of directors,
  • and heard that there was a change in leadership
  • at AIDS Rochester from the executive director
  • of the Southern Tier AIDS Program.
  • And so one thing led to another.
  • And the next thing you know, I was packing my bags
  • and moving to Rochester for the job.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Wow.
  • KEVIN INDOVINO: What year was that?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: That was in 1990.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: And that change in leadership
  • was from Jackie to Paula.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Correct.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: So you were here at the beginning of Paula's--
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Paula started two weeks before I did.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: OK.
  • Can you give us a picture of what the climate was
  • like at that point in terms of AIDS
  • being on the increase, funding the position
  • that the agency had in terms of providing services?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Sure.
  • We were located on Chestnut Street at the time
  • and had a small staff of about maybe twenty.
  • Funding was just starting to get momentum from New York State.
  • As you know, in 1983 is when AIDS Rochester was founded,
  • and some money was being released.
  • But as the AIDS epidemic started moving outside
  • of New York City and Upstate, funding increased nicely
  • over the years.
  • Back then, I remember during my interview
  • the ACT UP in Rochester had a few members,
  • and they were doing some protesting
  • around town for more services and more needs
  • for people with HIV and AIDS.
  • And I think, also, concurrently at that time,
  • Dr. Valenti was preparing to open up his clinic, Community
  • Health Network.
  • And coincidentally, right after I
  • began working at AIDS Rochester is when CHN opened its doors.
  • Back then, when people became infected,
  • we did a lot of crisis management with people,
  • because usually, within six months to a year,
  • they were dead.
  • So it was a lot of end of life.
  • A lot of supporting staff who were helping people--
  • young, healthy people-- who became ill very quickly
  • and died.
  • We had a house at the time, a duplex house,
  • here in Rochester called the ARIES house,
  • and we were able to house six people there
  • to help them sort of offset the high cost of housing.
  • And that was a wonderful thing.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Can you tell us where that was?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: That was on Hayward Avenue,
  • right behind the bus garage where RTS is on Main Street.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: OK.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: It was right behind there.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: At the time, did you have funding?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Yes.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: I mean--
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: We did.
  • We did.
  • There were some issues with the transition in leadership
  • around the state re-investing in AIDS Rochester
  • because of some things I really can't
  • get into for legal reasons.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Right.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: But we were able to, within six months
  • to a year, reestablish our credibility with New York State
  • and become pretty solid with the funding.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Did you ever lose funding in that transition?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: We did not.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: And was it from New York State,
  • or was it from the Fed?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: It was all New York state funding, primarily,
  • and local donations.
  • I think some foundations had invested in AIDS Rochester.
  • We weren't yet a United Way agency.
  • Paula and I, soon after starting,
  • became friendly with United Way, and we started
  • getting funding from them.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: OK.
  • Do you remember when federal funding started?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: That was probably in the mid-90s
  • when housing opportunities for people with AIDS
  • became available through HUD, and that
  • was pass-through money.
  • New York state handled some of the money and the city
  • of Rochester handled some of the money,
  • so we were able to get money for Monroe County
  • and also money for the rural areas that we served.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Was HPA in full swing?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: HPA was in full swing then and going
  • to Dining for Dollars.
  • They were very, very helpful and generous to us
  • in those early years.
  • Very supportive.
  • And Jeff Koss was our first development director,
  • so he was very closely affiliated with Helping People
  • with AIDS.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Right.
  • Do you remember who was in charge of HPA?
  • Besides Jeff's involvement, was it Tony Green?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Tony Green was--
  • I don't know if he was in charge of it,
  • but he was certainly high up on the ladder with them.
  • Tony was also on our board at AIDS Rochester.
  • In fact, we named our housing services, and to this day
  • it's called green house services.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Right.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Green housing services.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Talk to us a little bit about Tony.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Oh, Tony.
  • Well, Tony was pretty larger than life
  • in terms of his community involvement.
  • He had, I think, once been a bar owner
  • or a bartender here in town, and he knew everybody.
  • He was like the mayor.
  • And unfortunately, he was HIV positive also
  • and went through a lot of health issues because of that,
  • but never really lost his drive and his advocacy
  • for people with HPA and with housing services,
  • and stayed active with AIDS Rochester
  • right up until the end.
  • In fact, I believe Paula was with him shortly
  • before he died, or the day before.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Yes.
  • Yeah.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Yeah.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Larger than life.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Indeed.
  • Indeed.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Can you say a little bit more about that--
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: About Tony?
  • EVELYN BAILEY: --experience?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Tony was his own ACT UP.
  • He wasn't politically correct.
  • He was not shy about telling people exactly what he thought.
  • One of his things was if people didn't
  • put AIDS in all capital letters, he became vocal about that.
  • He was a friend to everyone.
  • He was a big softy on the inside,
  • but hard as nails on the outside.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Yeah.
  • Jim Black?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Jim Black was also on our board at that time.
  • And Jim was involved at the Forum quite a bit
  • and did a lot of fundraising through the Bachelor Forum
  • and with HPA also, and was a good friend to AIDS Rochester.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Yeah.
  • Share with us a little bit about your own--
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: I get teary talking about Tony.
  • I'm sorry.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Yeah.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: I still miss him.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: I know.
  • He was a incredible human being.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: He really was.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Talk to us a little bit
  • about your own reactions, your own sense or reason
  • why you had two friends that died from AIDS.
  • What did you find here in Rochester
  • in terms of community, in terms of people who were connected
  • to the AIDS crisis?
  • How did that impact you?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Well, I had a lot to compare it to.
  • You know, being involved with the Southern Tier AIDS
  • Program, which was in Binghamton,
  • a much smaller community than Rochester--
  • and when I came here, comparing the two,
  • Rochester seemed to be leaps and bounds ahead.
  • They had an organized fundraising committee, made up
  • of mostly gay men who were throwing
  • these fabulous fundraisers, raising hundreds of thousands
  • of dollars for community agencies.
  • And the spirit of the town, in terms
  • of not only the gay community but others, was very involved.
  • Very, very vocal and wanted to get more done.
  • You know?
  • Very impatient, and rightfully so.
  • There were so many things happening
  • that it was really hard to stay ahead of anything.
  • And I'll never forget the day that Magic Johnson
  • came out and said that he was HIV positive.
  • We answered our hotline at AIDS Rochester until almost midnight
  • that night, people calling.
  • And it really put a face on AIDS,
  • where there was fear and sort of people pushing away and saying
  • it's only a gay man's disease.
  • It doesn't really affect me.
  • It suddenly did.
  • And I remember Jeff and Paula and I and some
  • of our prevention staff were there
  • talking to people well into the night about their fears
  • around HIV infection.
  • It was really quite a night.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Wow.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: And then, of course,
  • when Rock Hudson was on the cover of,
  • I think, People Magazine as having died of AIDS,
  • that, again, generated a lot.
  • It was also good for fundraising.
  • It was good for-- people started giving money, because it really
  • put a face on this, that it was somebody else's problem.
  • Rock Hudson and Magic Johnson, these two celebrities
  • that sort of helped people know that it affected them too.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: It was OK for them
  • to share their experience--
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Right.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: --because of these--
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Yes.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: --figures who were so--
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Yes.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: --much in people's vision, sight.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: The other thing that I remember
  • loving and feeling so connected to here in Rochester
  • that I had not heard of before was Street Outreach.
  • And we had a staff member named Toni Obermeyer.
  • Don't know if you remember Toni.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: I do.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Another larger-than-life person
  • in the fight against HIV.
  • And she was a pioneer with Street Outreach programs.
  • She had been exposed to one in New York City.
  • And I remember it was probably--
  • I started in February, and I believe
  • it was in the summer, my first summer,
  • she took me out on Street Outreach.
  • And we went on Jefferson Avenue here in the city,
  • and she took me into a crack house.
  • And we walked right in there and she said, "Hello, everybody.
  • I'm Toni.
  • Here I am," and started passing out condoms and safer sex
  • information.
  • And testing was only by blood draw back then,
  • but she was-- everybody knew her.
  • She was this very large, white lesbian who trounced
  • the streets of Rochester talking to anybody and everybody about
  • HIV, and had a team of people with her and didn't--
  • she didn't care where she went or who she met.
  • She talked to them about AIDS.
  • So I just thought that was great.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: How did you feel going into that environment?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Strangely enough, I wasn't afraid,
  • because Toni was with me.
  • Had I been by myself, I probably would have
  • had a much different reaction.
  • KEVIN INDOVINO: Is she still around?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: No.
  • Tony unfortunately died-- oh, god, Bill will remember.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Ten or eleven years ago.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Yeah.
  • Yeah.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Yeah.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Yeah.
  • She left here, got married, and moved to New York
  • City, where she became--
  • she was a huge advocate for needle exchange
  • and became a pretty big mover and shaker
  • in New York City with the harm reduction movement down there.
  • Yeah, but she moved back to Rochester.
  • I actually saw her--
  • oh, god, she called me out of the blue and needed our help.
  • And so I went to her house and took some things
  • that she needed, and actually got to see her probably
  • about a week before she died.
  • It was great.
  • It was great to see her again.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: So what's your recollection of Jeff Koss?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Oh, Jeff.
  • Jeff was another larger-than-life guy
  • in my early AIDS life here.
  • He was so helpful to me in making connections and getting
  • me acquainted with the community and different people who
  • he thought I should know.
  • And he was very, very helpful in those early days.
  • Plus, he knew how to ask somebody for a dollar.
  • He wasn't afraid.
  • He believed very strongly in what we did.
  • And between Paula, Jeff, and myself,
  • we were sort of like the trio that
  • put the face on AIDS Rochester, and really got the community
  • to put their arms around AIDS Rochester
  • and support us in any way that they could.
  • And they did.
  • Jeff organized the first AIDS walk here in Rochester,
  • and I remember feeling so amazed by that feat.
  • It was an extravaganza, and we just
  • didn't know how it was going to work.
  • And he made it work, and it was great.
  • KEVIN INDOVINO: Michael, forgive me,
  • when you first started here, what was your title?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: I was the program director when
  • I started at AIDS Rochester.
  • And then about, oh, five years later
  • became the associate executive director.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: And when Jeff was not working at AIDS Rochester,
  • Miss Laverne came out very strongly.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: So I've been told.
  • I never saw that side of him, believe it or not.
  • I didn't.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Really?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Uh-uh.
  • I didn't.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Oh.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: I was very friendly with his partner,
  • Michael, but I didn't--
  • we didn't socialize a whole lot outside of the organization.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Right.
  • Talk to us a little bit about Paula
  • and how she kind of moved into AIDS Rochester at a very
  • difficult time, and then moved the agency forward
  • to where it was six, eight, ten months ago.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Right.
  • Well--
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Or a year ago.
  • Yeah.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: It's been almost two and a half years--
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Two and a half years.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: --believe it or not.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: It doesn't seem like that long.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: I know.
  • Well, actually, it's been two and a half years.
  • It was two and a half years --
  • KEVIN INDOVINO: Since the merge?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Yeah.
  • KEVIN INDOVINO: Wow.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Yeah.
  • KEVIN INDOVINO: Yeah, I wouldn't have guessed that.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Yeah.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Yeah.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: It feels like--
  • but anyways.
  • It feels a little longer to me.
  • Well, Paula, above anything else,
  • was a good fiscal manager.
  • She believed in saving money for a rainy day,
  • not putting all the money in one basket,
  • really, really managing money well.
  • And that's what AIDS Rochester needed.
  • It was in debt.
  • There were a lot of people who wanted to be paid.
  • And so she initially started taking all of that
  • apart and working closely with the board
  • and with the board's finance committee
  • to sort of write the agency and get it more solvent.
  • That was an amazing thing.
  • I immediately liked her when I met her during the interview,
  • and I thought her ideas were very solid.
  • She didn't profess to have all the answers.
  • And she wanted somebody in a program director
  • that could manage the programs and grow them, grow
  • and expand them.
  • And she didn't think of us as boss and subordinates.
  • She thought of us as partners, and that's what we were.
  • And we worked really hard.
  • A lot of seven-day weeks and lots of lots of hours.
  • There were lots and lots of problems with AIDS Rochester
  • when we took it over.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: If you were to name one thing that
  • drove Paula, what would it be?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: That drove her--
  • EVELYN BAILEY: To be so committed to--
  • I mean, a job is a job, but let's face it.
  • You don't put in twenty four-seven
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Right.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: --just because you got a job.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Well, Paula, from what
  • I know about her before my time here,
  • was very connected to the theater arts
  • community, the dancing community,
  • and as a result, the gay community.
  • And I think she also suffered her own losses
  • and her own tragedies around HIV and AIDS.
  • And like me, you know, made a commitment
  • to sort of make a dent in that in the community,
  • to try to help people at a time when people were so helpless.
  • It was a very, very, very different time than it is now.
  • So I think that's what drove her.
  • And also believing in the organization and its place
  • in the community then and why it was
  • so important to make AIDS Rochester really
  • the center where people could come and get what they needed,
  • HIV positive or not.
  • And that's sort of the way we always
  • ran it for the twenty years that we were together there.
  • KEVIN INDOVINO: I'm going to just kind of cuff out something
  • earlier that you just said.
  • In the course of your time here with AIDS Rochester
  • and eventually into the merger, if you
  • were to identify one major challenge that
  • needed to be overcome, or a challenge that's
  • a constant throughout those years,
  • what would be the major challenge
  • in regards to AIDS Rochester and its impact on the community?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: The stigma of HIV infection and homophobia.
  • Those are the two big ones that stay constant,
  • and I think still do to some degree.
  • When it--
  • KEVIN INDOVINO: And so then the second part of that question is
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Yes.
  • KEVIN INDOVINO: How do you overcome those challenges?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Well, it was really, really difficult,
  • and I don't think we've overcome them at all.
  • I think we diminish them to a great deal,
  • because the face of AIDS has changed
  • over these past 20-plus years.
  • People aren't dying anymore.
  • They don't have Kaposi's sarcoma.
  • They don't look like they have been starved for two years.
  • People are living with HIV now and look healthy.
  • It's really difficult to tell.
  • Back then, anyone that looked--
  • if someone had cancer, immediately,
  • before they said, oh, what's wrong?
  • Oh, you must have AIDS, and wouldn't go near them.
  • I remember Dr. Valenti had a patient.
  • He knew that I was in nursing, and he
  • wanted his patient to go to the Cleveland Clinic for a drug
  • trial.
  • This is way, way, way long time ago.
  • And I would need to pick up the patient at Highland Hospital
  • and get on a plane with him to fly to Cleveland,
  • and then take a taxi to the Cleveland Clinic,
  • get the patient admitted and come back, and then
  • go get him when this was done.
  • And we boarded a US air flight.
  • And this gentleman was probably in his early twenties,
  • and he was so sick.
  • And the flight attendants were so afraid to--
  • and everyone on the plane just looked at him,
  • and it was just awful.
  • I'll never forget that.
  • And this poor young man, who was just
  • so desperate to get better, who had put himself
  • through this just horrible, horrible atrocity of having
  • to get on a plane with looking the way that he did,
  • knowing how bad he looked and feeling embarrassed by that.
  • But adding to that, having the people
  • on the plane sort of look at him aghast because he
  • didn't look like them.
  • But the silver lining in that story
  • is when I went to pick him up, maybe a month or a month
  • and a half later, we get on a US airplane in Cleveland
  • to come back to Rochester, and we sat down in our seat
  • and he was even sicker.
  • The drug trial hadn't done its job.
  • And one of the flight attendants came up to me and she said,
  • we're putting you in first class.
  • Come on.
  • He'll be more comfortable and so will you.
  • It was a remarkable thing and they treated him like a king.
  • And he died shortly thereafter.
  • But that was just how it was then.
  • And you can probably remember that, Evelyn.
  • People were just so judgmental and so afraid
  • because they didn't understand it.
  • And there was so much that, you know,
  • you can get it from a toilet seat.
  • You can get it from shaking hands or hugging,
  • or sitting next to someone, or if they coughed.
  • You It was just irrational fear that took over.
  • So over time, that's gotten better,
  • but I'm still amazed at people who
  • I hear about through our prevention education
  • department who still don't understand
  • how HIV is transmitted.
  • There are still people in this community who
  • have closed their ears for all these years
  • and have chosen not to listen.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Yeah.
  • Yeah.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: And I'm surprised
  • that people are still getting infected
  • knowing what they know.
  • No judgment there, but knowing what they know
  • and still getting infected with HIV.
  • So we haven't overcome it all.
  • KEVIN INDOVINO: Yeah.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: And we've gotten a long way.
  • I think homophobia has diminished a great deal
  • over the years with the help of the Gay Alliance
  • and others in the community too, and sort
  • of in the national movement in the LGBT communities.
  • I think gay and lesbian people are
  • more normalized than they were.
  • There isn't all of the fear.
  • KEVIN INDOVINO: Oh my god, (unintelligible)
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Is that a hug?
  • Yeah, exactly.
  • How can you tell if they are one--
  • KEVIN INDOVINO: Right.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: --if they're not--
  • anyways.
  • So it's been a long road, but it's gotten better,
  • but we've got a ways to go.
  • We still do.
  • I mean, the challenge now is to help people understand
  • that HIV still is a problem in the community
  • and that you don't want to get infected,
  • because living with medication for the rest of your life
  • is not something that you want to do.
  • So the message has changed, but it's still the same.
  • You have to take care of yourself.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Right.
  • There was a point at which this disease, in a sense,
  • became less identified with the gay population
  • and more identified with the drug user--
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Oh, yes.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: --and the criminal population.
  • What impact did that change in, quote unquote, causation
  • have not only on AIDS Rochester but on the community?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Sure.
  • Well, as I mentioned Toni Obermeyer
  • earlier in our conversation, she was a big proponent
  • of handing out bleach kits to clean needles and syringes
  • to drug users.
  • And we did that, but HIV infection in the injecting drug
  • user community was on the rise at a remarkable rate
  • here in Rochester and elsewhere in the country.
  • And a woman by the name of Lisa Perticone,
  • who was very much involved with the harm reduction movement
  • and was getting her master's degree,
  • became an intern of mine at AIDS Rochester.
  • And she started telling me about needle exchange programs that
  • were happening in larger cities across the United States.
  • Not in New York.
  • Mostly in San Francisco.
  • One in Oregon.
  • And so we helped petition New York State Department of Health
  • to decriminalize syringes in New York State
  • and allow them to be exchanged one for one
  • in programs that were heavily sanctioned and regulated
  • by New York State.
  • So eventually, New York State agreed
  • to do that throughout the state, but you
  • had to go through a rigorous community engagement
  • process in order to get one approved in your city.
  • And so Paula and I became the community ambassadors
  • for a needle exchange.
  • And I can tell you that it wasn't pretty,
  • and there were a lot of people who were vehemently
  • against this program.
  • And we were spit at and called the devil,
  • and had things thrown at us and telephone
  • calls to the organization that were hateful,
  • but we plugged on.
  • And we had a number of community meetings
  • here with the New York State Department of Health officials,
  • and eventually our program was approved.
  • We looked at seroprevalence just before the program started,
  • and it was very high in the injecting drug user community.
  • Within eighteen months, it had dropped almost 50 percent
  • because of the amount of clean syringes
  • that we were able to put into the drug using system.
  • And we had those results verified by Sloan Kettering
  • Hospital.
  • They came up and did some independent research.
  • So the program continues today, and it's
  • served well over 6,000 people during its lifetime.
  • And it has shown to not only reduce
  • HIV infection in injecting drug users,
  • but that's been a sustainable decrease.
  • It's a low number now, low number
  • of people who are becoming infected that way.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Was the opposition
  • you experienced to this not--
  • was it across the board?
  • Was it the gay community, the heterosexual community,
  • the political community, the economic community?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Well--
  • EVELYN BAILEY: I mean--
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: I can tell you, early on, hardly anyone--
  • we had a core group of community members
  • that supported the program and helped us,
  • and one of the people that came to the very first meeting
  • and never stopped coming to meetings and speaking out
  • was Bob Duffy.
  • Bob Duffy was the lieutenant police chief at that time.
  • I remember him coming, and I had never met him before.
  • And he sat there and he said, why aren't we doing this?
  • This makes total sense to me.
  • Why aren't we doing this?
  • And so he became a very large figure
  • in the movement in this community
  • by getting Paula and I appointments with Howard Relin,
  • the district attorney at the time
  • who did not support the program, with other people in city
  • and county government-- some who supported, some who did not.
  • It was largely divided along political lines, Republicans
  • and Democrats.
  • He never missed a meeting.
  • He always supported the program.
  • And in fact, when I saw him at Paula's retirement party,
  • I thanked him again for the work that he did.
  • Because I truly believe that without him and others like him
  • in the community, that program would not exist.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Was there any violence?
  • I mean, I know you indicated that you were spat
  • upon and catcalled, but was there any violence
  • that erupted because of this?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: No, but I can tell you what did happen.
  • On our first day, we used-- we didn't have a fixed office.
  • We had a mobile van that we had three sites
  • that we were approved to do syringe exchange out
  • of our outreach van, and one of the sites
  • was on Jefferson Avenue.
  • So of course the media was very involved in this.
  • And on the day that it opened, a reporter from Channel 10
  • came to AIDS Rochester and interviewed Paula, I believe.
  • Simultaneously, they had hired an actor
  • with a backpack with a hidden camera that walked up
  • to the needle exchange site and said to the worker,
  • I'm thinking about shooting drugs.
  • I'm not shooting them yet, but I'd like to start.
  • Can you give me a needle?
  • And the staff at that time did--
  • the gentleman said, our staff said,
  • why do you want to start injecting drugs?
  • That's crazy.
  • Why do you want to do that?
  • And no, I'm not going to give-- that's not why we're here.
  • Well, they ran that story.
  • And we fought that pretty hard because the program's
  • anonymous, and the users who are coming to that site
  • were being filmed secretly from a different location.
  • And that kind of crackpot journalism,
  • I guess, if you call it, just--
  • I've never forgotten it.
  • And I still see that reporter on the air on the morning
  • news on Channel 10--
  • she's still there-- who sensationalized that story.
  • Other media were very friendly.
  • And we've had ups and downs with the community over the years
  • with it.
  • Mayor Johnson was very supportive.
  • But when the community got a little agitated,
  • he became a little agitated and wanted
  • us to help calm things down.
  • And we did.
  • But he was a wonderful partner in this.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Well, the reporter
  • smacks a little bit of the paparazzi kind of--
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Oh, it was totally--
  • KEVIN INDOVINO: Yeah.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: I think still have--
  • KEVIN INDOVINO: I think I know who you're talking about.
  • She was young and just getting started. (Beatty laughs)
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Talk to Kevin and I a little bit
  • about your own experience in dealing
  • with the Hispanic and black community here in Rochester
  • in terms of support, in terms of behind the scenes,
  • in front of the scenes.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Sure.
  • Well.
  • The minority community, primarily African-American
  • and Latino, there was a huge sense
  • of denial in both of those communities around HIV
  • infection and sort of everything associated with it.
  • No one really wanted to talk about it.
  • And the few who did and who tried to, who had
  • emerged as leaders--
  • Rudy Rivera was one of them--
  • had a very difficult time sort of engaging people.
  • They were seen as leaders in the community,
  • yet it was really difficult for him and others
  • to engage and talk about HIV infection,
  • because that was a huge shame because of the behaviors
  • associated with contracting it.
  • As numbers started to rise in terms of HIV infections
  • in both of those communities, we partnered with ABC
  • and, excuse me, PRYD primarily and Ibero to work together
  • in the community to--
  • we had the credibility around HIV and AIDS
  • because we had been around for so long and ABC
  • and Ibero and PRYD were sort of newcomers to the HIV world.
  • And they received some funding and we were a lot together
  • in the communities to try to get the message out.
  • I mean, it was very difficult because no one wanted
  • to talk about it, and largely, I think,
  • because of religion and also the homosexuality and drug use.
  • And no one really wanted to talk about those problems
  • or what they perceived were problems in their community.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: As you look back over the past twenty, thirty
  • years, can you identify for us--
  • I usually say one, but I'll say two or three--
  • things that you are most proud of having been involved with,
  • started, begun?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Yes.
  • There's a lot.
  • I'm really, really proud of AIDS Rochester, because I believe
  • that originally, from '83 to '90,
  • AIDS Rochester lived a very different life before Paula
  • and I got there, and a life that was no less diminished
  • by anything.
  • It had its place, and it was a wonderful haven
  • for people at that time.
  • The problem outgrew the agency's ability
  • to deal with it, unfortunately, and so things happened.
  • And I really believe that--
  • and I'm very proud of what Paula and I were
  • able to do at AIDS Rochester and for the community.
  • And the other is the needle exchange program.
  • That was a very, very, very tough battle, and we--
  • it wasn't just Paula and I. It was
  • the engagement of a lot of very powerful people
  • in the community, influential people in the community, that
  • got that program going, and it had a remarkable effect
  • and reduced infections among people
  • who were already very fragile.
  • And we've helped so many people not only with
  • their clean syringes, but getting them into treatment
  • and helping them inject their drugs safely
  • so that other issues around injection drug use
  • didn't crop up for them.
  • So those are two big things.
  • And if I can say one more, I'm very proud of the merge.
  • I think that the time had really come for AIDS Community Health
  • Center and AIDS Rochester to come together.
  • You know, it's funny.
  • Early on, we had a meeting with Bill,
  • and Sue Cowell, I believe, was there, and Paula and myself,
  • and we talked about merging.
  • I think that was, like, in 1992.
  • And we thought, you know, what a great thing we could become.
  • And it just didn't work out at the time.
  • The timing wasn't right.
  • And so two and a half years ago it was.
  • And we came together again, and we
  • created an even more dynamic organization because of it.
  • And I'm very proud to have been, in large part, a leader in that
  • merge.
  • KEVIN INDOVINO: Can you speak to--
  • there seems to be, you know-- there
  • was a time where the community was very supportive of AIDS
  • awareness and AIDS care, and then
  • we kind of reached a climax, and then
  • it really kind of took a dove.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Right.
  • KEVIN INDOVINO: From your experience from the inside,
  • tell me what you saw and what you witnessed.
  • And again, how did you deal with those influxes?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Sure.
  • Well, the same thing.
  • You know, as I said earlier, I liken it to these commercials
  • that you see on TV for children with cancer or animals
  • who have been abused, and these horrific pictures
  • and the heart-wrenching music and reaching out
  • to people to give, to help these people or these poor pets.
  • And that's the way it used to be.
  • People looked so sick.
  • Young, healthy men and women looking like they
  • were a hundred years old and celebrities dying.
  • And then, around '95 or '96 when the new medications came out,
  • I literally witnessed men and women regaining their health.
  • They looked like they were at death's door,
  • and they regained their health.
  • Some of them went back to work.
  • And they gained their weight.
  • Their faces filled out.
  • They looked as healthy as all of us.
  • But soon, the outward appearance of somebody with HIV and AIDS
  • and then living longer didn't have the same emotional appeal
  • to the community.
  • Because they believed that their dollar was helping
  • save somebody's life or help making
  • them comfortable in their last hours of life,
  • and that retreated when people started living with HIV.
  • And so the way we've overcome that is that we've really
  • tried hard to keep the communities who
  • are most invested in HIV and AIDS connected
  • to it, because no one really knows how
  • long the medications will work.
  • There was not a lot of testing done.
  • Medications got approved very quickly and put on the market.
  • And yes, we predict people to live a long time now
  • with this chronic illness, but no one really knows.
  • If another strain of the infection comes--
  • I mean, anything-- a tipping point
  • could come again with this infection.
  • No one knows.
  • And so we want to keep people engaged not necessarily
  • with that message, but with them, you know,
  • you were there for us before.
  • Stay with us and help people get into care.
  • Because without the care, they're
  • not going to do well with HIV.
  • Have donations dropped?
  • Yes, they have.
  • We've seen that drop slightly over the years.
  • And I remember hundreds of walkers coming every June
  • to our AIDS walk annually, and this year we
  • had eighty-eight people there that had registered to walk.
  • You know, and that speaks volumes,
  • because the connection--
  • the people who used to march in memory of their loved ones,
  • there were very few of those.
  • I think time has passed and people have moved on.
  • And the memories are painful, and perhaps they
  • don't want to go back there again.
  • So I think there's lots of reasons.
  • And so one of the things we decided to do at AIDS care
  • in our strategic plan is not lose sight of HIV and AIDS,
  • but to look also in an outer circle
  • of care for people who may be vulnerable or at risk for HIV.
  • And those are substance users, people with hepatitis C,
  • and also the LGBT community.
  • And so we're moving in that direction now.
  • We will never lose our heart, which is HIV and AIDS,
  • but we will try to expand our services to people
  • who are vulnerable in other ways, who may be marginalized
  • because the health care that they need isn't there for them
  • without judgment.
  • So here we will be a health care organization
  • without judgment and specialized in whenever people need.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: The numbers are rising, though.
  • Aren't they?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: With HIV?
  • Not as rapidly as they once were.
  • People are still getting infected.
  • We still have all of our grants to fight infection.
  • I think we're making progress there.
  • Our needle exchange program is still as busy as ever.
  • You know, that's not going away.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: The younger generation
  • under the age of thirty really does not
  • have a picture of this disease that
  • is unpleasant or difficult to look at.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Right.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: As an AIDS educator,
  • as the CEO now of AIDS care, what would you say to someone
  • who was in their twenties about behavior,
  • about activity that would hopefully impact their thought
  • process, their--
  • or is there anything?
  • Is this the age of--
  • I'll never die.
  • Nothing's ever going to happen to me.
  • I'm not going to get that.
  • I'm not-- what would you say?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Well, I would say google HIV and AIDS
  • in the 1980s and 1990s, and read and look at pictures
  • and read the history.
  • If you're gay, you should understand
  • the history of the gay community that you live in.
  • And you should know how many people in this community
  • came before you, who-- some lived and some died,
  • but they fought to get where we are today with HIV and AIDS.
  • And we should pay them respect and some homage.
  • But it also would help people understand
  • what it was like then.
  • There's nothing that I can say to someone that
  • will change their behavior.
  • People change their behaviors for multitudes of reasons.
  • Whatever myth, whatever belief system
  • that an individual person has, such as--
  • I can tell when somebody has AIDS.
  • If I have sex with somebody over thirty-five
  • I would probably use a condom.
  • But if I had sex with somebody a little bit younger,
  • I wouldn't need a condom, because they're probably
  • not infected.
  • Or I can tell just by looking at them that they're infected.
  • And even if I do get infected, there's
  • a pill I can take to eradicate the infection.
  • So there's all of those myths--
  • some with a little truth in them, some
  • that are all not true--
  • but those are pervasive in the young--
  • and I was a young man once.
  • And so were my friends.
  • They were young when they became infected, and they knew.
  • I mean, HIV was around then, and we heard about it.
  • And they became infected, and they
  • died, because you don't think it's going to happen to you.
  • That feeling never changes, I think, in young people,
  • that it's somebody else's problem
  • and it'll never happen to me.
  • And then it does.
  • And then you have to deal.
  • And I would also encourage them to talk
  • with a peer who is HIV positive and hear from their peer
  • what it's like to have to take the medication every day
  • and deal with the side effects and what restrictions HIV has
  • put on their lives.
  • Because that, I think, sometimes, is the most powerful
  • thing, is when you talk to somebody who is like you in age
  • and sex and behavior.
  • And that can be a motivator to change.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: I have a couple more questions.
  • Hazel Jeffries was chair of AIDS Rochester board
  • for a number of years.
  • Do you remember when that began, maybe, and when?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: I do.
  • I think that she came on the board, I want to say 1988,
  • because she was on the board through the transition--
  • excuse me-- with Jackie and then hiring Paula,
  • and stayed with our board--
  • oh, golly-- '94 maybe, '95.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: She was a doc.
  • No.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: No, no.
  • At the time, she worked for ABC, I
  • believe, and then move to Catholic Charities,
  • and then retired.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Is she still in Rochester?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: I don't know.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: OK.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: We honored her at our 20th, AIDS Rochester's
  • 20th anniversary, and I don't remember hearing much from her
  • since then.
  • We invited her to Paula's retirement party,
  • and I don't believe they heard back.
  • I know that she lost her husband.
  • And so I don't know.
  • I don't know.
  • I would love to know where she is.
  • Was a great woman.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: She was obviously a woman with vision
  • and a woman who was able to negotiate and navigate
  • the waters of that transition.
  • How would you describe her?
  • What would you say about her tenacity?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Oh, her tenacity was unsurpassed
  • in terms of staying the course.
  • Hazel was a calm presence when everything around her
  • was falling apart.
  • She had wonderful judgment.
  • She had excellent communications skills.
  • She knew exactly what to do.
  • And I'm sure, in her mind, she said,
  • what the hell do I do next?
  • But she just kept moving forward.
  • And eventually things, as most crises do,
  • dissipate, but she never faltered.
  • She's an amazing woman.
  • Amazing woman.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: How significant has Bill Valenti been pre-CHN,
  • CHN, AIDS Care, in the battle?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Well, we don't have enough time for me
  • to go into all of it, but I didn't know Bill before CHN
  • I met Bill and Dr. Scheibel at the Bachelor Forum right
  • after I moved to Rochester.
  • I hadn't even started my job yet.
  • And Steve Scheibel, Bill's medical partner,
  • lived across the street from Paula
  • at the time in the 19th Ward.
  • And so Paula was trying to get me introduced.
  • I was new to Rochester.
  • And so Bill and Steve and Paula and myself
  • and, I don't remember, someone else
  • went to the Bachelor Forum, and we all sort of
  • talked about CHN, sort of the preview of what
  • it was going to be.
  • And they were both so proud.
  • And I was just amazed at how these two men, two doctors,
  • had been able to gain the support of this community
  • in a way that I had never heard of before to get funding,
  • to get a building, to get furniture,
  • to get people to come around them
  • to make this clinic a reality.
  • It's one thing to have a dream, but it's another thing
  • to be able to live that dream.
  • And that's what they did.
  • And Bill, he's just been there through all this,
  • through all these years, long before I got here
  • when he was at the U of R in the early days.
  • He knows everybody.
  • He's so well connected.
  • But his passion has never died.
  • It's never flickered, to my knowledge,
  • and I've known him all these years.
  • And he and I work very closely here together now.
  • He's a great man.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Jay Redman.
  • Now, I know he's a doc.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: He is not a doctor.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: No.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Jay is our chief executive officer.
  • I'm the chief operating officer.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Right.
  • But Jay has been in this for a long time.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Just, I think, ten years
  • he's been the CEO of the organization.
  • He was obviously very involved in the merge with Paula and I.
  • And Jay came from working in health systems.
  • I'm not sure what his last position was,
  • but he has been really one of the very first leaders of CHN,
  • ACHC that has stabilized that organization.
  • There were very turbulent times for CHN and ACHC
  • over the years.
  • It was a brand new organization, and there
  • were a lot of fragilities in navigating
  • providing health care.
  • Back then, health care was very, very, very expensive
  • for people with HIV and AIDS.
  • And many times, insurance didn't cover a lot of the things
  • that Bill and Steve Scheibel provided.
  • That didn't stop them, and they just kept finding money.
  • So the organization on financial terms was fragile.
  • And when Jay came along, he really
  • brought that business sense with him
  • from an administrative point of view.
  • Much like with Jackie and then Paula,
  • the same thing sort of mirrored itself.
  • You know, CHN lived its life in the world
  • that it needed to live and provided the care for people
  • when it needed to be there.
  • But then things changed, and that's when Jay came out,
  • just like with Paula, and righted the organization
  • and put it on solid ground.
  • He's a great guy, too.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: So Michael.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Evelyn.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Twenty years from now--
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Oh, god.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: --when people talk about Michael Beatty, what
  • do you want them to say?
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Oh, boy.
  • I don't think I've ever been asked that question.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Well, and if you want to put off the answer,
  • that's fine.
  • I mean, I ask that of most of the people we interview,
  • because we never know when we're going through something
  • the impact of it.
  • I mean, the people who started Gay Live at the U of R forty
  • years ago never imagined--
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Right.
  • Right.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: --could not even think the thoughts
  • of what it would have become, and didn't really think
  • they were doing anything other than what they
  • had to do to be who they were.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: I'll tell you a story.
  • When I took this job, I said to Paula,
  • I'll take it for three years, because I'm
  • going to miss nursing so much that I'm going
  • to want to go back to that.
  • But I'll get you through, and I'll stay for three years.
  • That's been almost twenty-three years ago that I said that.
  • So what I hope people--
  • this has always been more than a job for me.
  • It's been something that I have done to honor my friends,
  • and it's been--
  • that's why I originally did it.
  • And I've never lost sight of what I'm doing.
  • It's always been more than that for me in that I believe
  • that a group of people can make a difference in the community.
  • And I believe that back in those-- and still today,
  • back in the day and today, that we have made
  • a difference in this community.
  • There have been so many things that I
  • had a dream about doing with AIDS Rochester
  • and even AIDS Care that became a reality.
  • And I've learned a lot along the way,
  • and I have not one regret for all that I've been through.
  • And so I'm going to keep going for a while.
  • There's some other dreams that I have
  • that I want to make a reality, and then it'll
  • be time to retire.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: OK.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: OK.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Michael, thank you.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: You're welcome.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Very much.
  • MICHAEL BEATTY: Thank you.
  • My pleasure.
  • EVELYN BAILEY: Very much.
  • I'm going to turn this--